Millions of households across England and Wales could face changes to their council tax bills under Labour’s proposed police force shake-up. The plans have sparked opposition from police and crime commissioners, who warn that the changes could leave many residents paying more.
11 Million Households Could Face Higher Council Tax Bills
Labour’s proposals would reduce the number of police forces in England and Wales from 43 to as few as nine regional forces. According to figures cited by The Telegraph, around 11 million households could face higher council tax bills as charges are aligned across the newly created forces.
Some properties could see their annual bills rise by as much as £70. Around five million households currently covered by forces with higher council tax charges could see their bills fall under the proposed system.
The changes would therefore redistribute the cost of local police services, with some residents paying more and others paying less.
Surrey and Northumbria Face Different Council Tax Rates
There are currently substantial differences in the amounts households pay towards local policing. For a Band D property, the annual police precept stands at:
| Police force area | Annual Band D precept |
|---|---|
| Surrey | £353 |
| Northumbria | £214 |
The £139 difference highlights the gap between the highest and lowest police precepts. Under the proposed mergers, these differences would need to be addressed through a common regional charge.
This could result in higher bills for households currently living in areas with lower police precepts.
31 Police Commissioners Urge Andy Burnham to Scrap the Plans
A cross-party group of 31 police and crime commissioners (PCCs) has written to Prime Minister Andy Burnham, calling for the proposed mergers to be abandoned. The group includes Labour, Conservative, Reform and independent commissioners.
They argue that creating large regional police forces could weaken local accountability and reduce the connection between police services and the communities they serve. In their letter, they warned that the creation of nine regional forces could lead to council tax increases for millions of households.
They also questioned whether residents should face higher charges during a cost-of-living crisis to finance the restructuring.
Commissioners Warn of Weaker Local Policing
The commissioners have raised concerns about the effect of larger forces on local crime prevention and public confidence. They argue that merging existing constabularies could dilute democratic accountability and make it harder for communities to hold their local police services responsible.
Their letter stated: “All of the benefits of devolution for public safety, policing and the wider criminal justice system would be lost.“
The group also warned that the democratic link between police forces and the public could be weakened by the creation of regional organisations.
Home Office Rejects the Council Tax Figures
The Home Office has challenged the estimates surrounding the proposed council tax changes. A spokesman described the figures as “purely speculative“ and said the reforms would deliver strong local policing to tackle neighbourhood crime.
The Government’s proposals remain controversial, particularly over how the new regional forces would be financed and how existing differences in police precepts would be addressed.
For households, the main concern is whether the restructuring could lead to higher annual council tax bills at a time when many families are already facing pressure on their budgets.








