In a move that has sparked intense debate, former President Donald Trump issued two executive orders on Monday that could significantly alter the trajectory of two rapidly growing climate-friendly technologies in the U.S.: electric vehicles (EVs) and wind power. The orders directly counter efforts by the Biden administration to accelerate the adoption of these technologies, which have been central to the nation’s push to decarbonize its energy market.
The timing of these orders is notable, as both EVs and wind power have seen unprecedented growth in recent years. However, Trump’s actions have reignited a contentious debate over the role of government in shaping the future of energy and transportation.
Rolling Back EV Progress: A Blow to Innovation or a Win for Consumers?
One of Trump’s executive orders reversed several climate-focused directives, most notably the tailpipe emissions standards designed to encourage the adoption of electric vehicles. During his campaign, Trump criticized these standards as an “EV mandate,” arguing that they forced consumers to buy expensive electric vehicles.
Implications of the EV Order:
- Reversal of Emissions Standards: The order eliminates stricter tailpipe emissions rules, which were seen as a catalyst for automakers to invest in EV technology.
- Impact on U.S. Competitiveness: Critics argue that the move could hinder the U.S. auto industry’s ability to compete globally, particularly against Chinese manufacturers.
- Consumer Choice: Proponents claim the order protects consumers from being pushed into purchasing higher-cost EVs.
Max Boykoff, director of the Center for Science and Technology Policy Research at the University of Colorado Boulder, warned of the broader consequences:“We suffer, we lose out, we squander opportunities by taking these kinds of actions. Because other nations will then be able to step forward and fill that gap.
Absolutely, Chinese companies are already outpacing the American electric vehicle market, and they’re ready to do more.” Despite the backlash, the Trump administration has not publicly responded to criticisms of the order.
Wind Power Under Fire: A Misguided Energy Strategy?
The second executive order temporarily halted federal approvals for lease sales of offshore wind projects and restricted new permits or loans for both onshore and offshore wind developments. Trump justified the move by claiming that wind power drives up energy costs and poses risks to marine life, particularly whales.
However, these claims have been widely disputed. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has found no evidence linking offshore wind turbines to whale deaths.
Points of Contention:
- Economic Impact: Blocking wind power projects could stifle job growth and investment in the renewable energy sector.
- Environmental Claims: Trump’s assertion that wind turbines harm marine life lacks scientific backing.
- Energy Costs: Critics argue that wind power is one of the most cost-effective energy sources available today.
Jason Grumet, CEO of the American Clean Power Association, criticized the order, calling it contradictory to Trump’s broader energy goals:“The contradiction between the energy-focused Executive Orders is stark: while on one hand the Administration seeks to reduce bureaucracy and unleash energy production, on the other it increases bureaucratic barriers, undermining domestic energy development and harming American businesses and workers.”
The Broader Context: A Shift in Energy Policy
Trump’s orders come at a pivotal moment for both EVs and wind power.
Electric Vehicles:
- Market Growth: Electric and hybrid vehicles accounted for a record 20% of new car sales in the U.S. last year, according to CNBC.
- Global Projections: An S&P Global analysis predicts that by 2030, more than 25% of new passenger cars sold globally will be electric.
Wind Power:
- Energy Capacity: The U.S. Energy Information Administration forecasts that wind and solar will dominate new energy capacity additions by 2050.
- Recent Milestones: In March and April 2023, offshore wind power generated more electricity in the U.S. than coal.
Despite these advancements, challenges such as rising commodity costs and supply chain disruptions have threatened the growth of wind power, according to consulting firm McKinsey.
Legal and Economic Fallout: What’s Next?
Trump’s executive orders are likely to face legal challenges, particularly the move to revoke California’s ability to set its own EV standards. California’s regulations, which aim to ban new gasoline-powered cars by 2032, have been adopted by 11 other states.
Paul Cort, a former Environmental Protection Agency attorney now with Earthjustice, questioned the legal basis for Trump’s order:
“California’s regulations are not just about addressing climate change. These rules were created so that California, which struggles with pollution issues, could meet its air quality and smog standards. What’s their legal standing for saying California can’t clean up its cars?”
Zara Ahmed, vice president of policy and advisory operations at Carbon Direct, emphasized the long-term economic risks of Trump’s actions:
“It’s a short-term political choice with potential long-term economic harm.”
A Provocative Perspective: Is Resistance to Clean Tech Futile
While Trump’s executive orders may slow the adoption of EVs and wind power in the short term, many experts believe they cannot halt the broader transition to clean energy.
Why the Clean Tech Transition May Be Inevitable:
- Global Momentum: Nations worldwide are investing heavily in renewable energy and EVs, creating a competitive global market.
- Economic Realities: The declining costs of renewable energy and battery technology make clean tech increasingly accessible.
- Public Demand: Growing awareness of climate change is driving consumer and corporate demand for sustainable solutions.
As Ahmed noted, “Trump’s regulations would not stop the inevitable march of the clean tech transition.”
Got a reaction? Share your thoughts in the comments
Enjoyed this article? Subscribe to our free Newsletter for captivating articles, exclusive content, and the latest news.
