California-based Straus Family Creamery has issued a voluntary recall of several organic ice cream products after discovering the potential presence of metal fragments. The recall affects products sold in 17 states, including California, Texas, Florida, New Jersey, and Washington.
Which Products Are Affected
The recall applies to specific flavors and sizes with designated “best by” dates. Vanilla Bean Ice Cream in pint sizes with best by dates of December 23 and December 28, 2026, is included. Strawberry Ice Cream in quart and pint sizes with best by dates of December 24 and December 25, 2026, Cookie Dough Ice Cream in pint size with a best by date of December 26, 2026.
The Dutch Chocolate Ice Cream in quart size with a best by date of December 27, 2026, and Mint Chip Ice Cream in pint size with a best by date of December 30, 2026, are part of the recall too. Customers can verify whether their ice cream is affected by checking the UPC numbers listed on the FDA website.
Guidance for Consumers
Consumers are advised not to eat any recalled products. Straus Family Creamery has instructed customers to discard the affected ice cream and not return it to stores. At this time, no injuries have been reported, but the recall is a precautionary measure to prevent potential harm from ingesting metal fragments.
The FDA emphasizes the importance of checking the lot numbers and best by dates carefully to ensure no recalled product is consumed.
Distribution and Scope of the Recall
The recalled products were distributed across Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Maryland, New Jersey, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Texas, Washington, and Wisconsin, says NBCNews.
The ice cream products were first available on store shelves beginning May 4, 2026, and the recall only applies to the specific lots and best by dates listed. Retailers are working to remove affected items from shelves, and the company is cooperating fully with authorities to ensure public safety.
Company Statement and Safety Measures
Straus Family Creamery emphasized that customer safety is their top priority. The company is coordinating with retailers and distributors to ensure all recalled products are removed from shelves promptly. Straus Family Creamery has also advised consumers to visit the FDA website for full details, including lot numbers and UPC codes, and to follow the guidance if they have purchased any affected items.
This recall serves as a reminder of the importance of monitoring food safety notices, even for trusted organic brands. By acting quickly and following FDA guidance, consumers can avoid potential health risks. Straus Family Creamery continues to monitor the situation closely and provide updates to protect consumers, reinforcing its commitment to safety and quality.
With dozens of ice cream flavors impacted across multiple states, the recall demonstrates how widespread issues can affect families nationwide and highlights the ongoing need for vigilance when it comes to food safety.
