The second phase of the UK government’s pensions review, which was meant to focus on whether contributions into workplace pensions are sufficient for retirement, has been postponed. Initially expected to begin by the end of 2024, the government now says details will be announced “in due course.” Experts fear this delay could have significant long-term consequences, exacerbating the risk of a retirement crisis for millions of savers.
The review’s delay comes at a time when questions around retirement adequacy have become more pressing. Under the current auto-enrolment system, workers and employers are required to contribute a minimum of 8% of qualifying earnings into pension pots. However, calls to raise this to 12% have grown louder, with research showing that current contributions are unlikely to meet future retirement needs.
While the government cites concerns about economic strain on businesses, particularly following increased national insurance contributions announced in the last Budget, critics argue that inaction today will compound financial challenges for retirees in the decades ahead.
Experts Warn of an Unfolding Crisis
Leading voices in the pensions sector have not shied away from highlighting the risks of delaying pension reforms. Tom Selby, director of public policy at AJ Bell, issued a stark warning:
“The longer we delay tackling the adequacy challenge, the bigger the risk to society of a future retirement crisis. With the economy still stuttering and the new government insisting economic growth remains its central objective, tackling pensions adequacy… may have slipped down the priority list.”
Similarly, Sir Steve Webb, former pensions minister, echoed these sentiments, emphasising the damage caused by inaction:
“Absolutely, a delay to this review will damage people’s retirements – it really matters… As soon as [Chancellor] Reeves sat down after that Budget I thought the chance [for reform] had massively decreased.”
The need for action is clear. Analysis from Phoenix Group shows that raising the minimum auto-enrolment contributions from 8% to 12% could add nearly £96,000 to a typical worker’s pension pot over their career. For younger savers, this additional sum could make the difference between financial security and struggling to make ends meet in retirement.
The Challenges of Reform and the Pressure on Businesses
The delay in addressing pension adequacy reflects a broader tension between supporting workers’ retirement needs and managing the economic pressures faced by businesses. Employers already contend with rising costs, including higher national insurance contributions and a planned increase in the national living wage next year.
A pensions reform that mandates higher contributions would undoubtedly increase financial pressure on employers, especially small businesses. However, experts argue that the long-term consequences of insufficient contributions are far more severe. Without reforms, millions of people may face a retirement income that falls short of the minimum living standard set by the Pensions and Lifetime Savings Association.
Catherine Foot, director at Phoenix Insights, stressed the urgency of addressing these issues:
“Hitting pause on the retirement adequacy review could have a huge detrimental effect on people’s financial future… Increasing minimum auto-enrolment contributions is one of the biggest levers to tackle undersaving, and we cannot afford to delay setting out a plan.”
Why Workplace Pensions Need Reform
The current auto-enrolment system, introduced in 2012, has been a success in many ways. It has brought millions of workers into pension saving for the first time. However, the 8% contribution rate—split between employers and employees—was always seen as a minimum, not a target.
Recent studies show that:
- 30-40% of savers in defined contribution pensions are on track to fall below the minimum retirement living standard.
- Incrementally raising contributions to 12% could close much of this savings gap.
- Delaying reform pushes the burden onto future generations and risks deepening financial inequality in retirement.
The challenge is compounded by demographic trends, including increasing life expectancy and the decline of more generous defined benefit pensions, which have largely disappeared from the private sector.
What Savers Can Do Now to Protect Their Retirement
While the government debates reform, individuals can take proactive steps to improve their retirement outlook. Financial experts recommend the following actions:
- Maximise Employer Contributions
Check if your employer offers matching contributions above the legal minimum. Contributing more now can boost your pension savings significantly. - Review Your Investment Strategy
If you are far from retirement, consider taking more risk by allocating a greater portion of your pension to stocks rather than bonds to achieve higher long-term growth. - Track Down Old Pensions
If you’ve changed jobs frequently, you may have forgotten pension pots. Consolidating these can help you manage and grow your savings more effectively. - Save More Independently
Consider contributing to a private pension or an Individual Savings Account (ISA) to supplement your workplace pension.
Got a reaction? Share your thoughts in the comments
Enjoyed this article? Subscribe to our free newsletter for engaging stories, exclusive content, and the latest news.
